News

Hard shell vs soft shell suitcases: which should you buy?

Hard shells protect and wipe clean; soft shells expand, squeeze into lockers and have pockets. Which suits your trip, with weights and sizes from our ranges.

Hard shell vs soft shell suitcases: which should you buy?

A hard shell suitcase protects what is inside, keeps its shape under other bags and wipes clean. A soft shell suitcase has give, so it squeezes into a car boot or an overhead rack, it usually weighs less, it expands, and it has outside pockets. Neither is better. Hard shells suit fragile contents, rough handling and wet weather; soft shells suit overpackers, car travel and anyone who wants a pocket for the documents. Here is how to choose, with the weights and sizes of ours.

Side by side

Hard shell and soft shell suitcases compared
  Hard shell Soft shell
Protection Better against crushing and knocks Depends on what is packed round the edges
Weight 2.7 to 3 kg for a cabin case, 4.2 to 4.6 kg for a 28 inch About 2.3 kg for a cabin case, 3.3 to 3.5 kg for a 28 inch
Expanding Some ranges, by a zip gusset Most ranges
Pockets Rarely Usually a front pocket or two
Packing Opens flat in two halves; needs the straps Opens like a lid; one deep compartment
Rain Water runs off; the zip is the only way in Fabric wets through in heavy rain
Scuffs Show, wipe off Hide, but tears do not mend
Squeezing into tight spaces No Yes
Cabin sizer Fits or does not Can be pressed in, but bulges if overpacked
Hard shell vs soft shell suitcases: which should you buy?

Choose a hard shell if

  • You check it in. The hold is where cases get crushed, and a shell keeps the shape.
  • You carry anything fragile or anything that leaks.
  • You fly to wet places, or stand in the rain at the taxi rank.
  • You want a combination lock built in, which most of our hard shells have.

Most of our hard shells are ABS: Grays, Curve, Flint, Ocean, the Squares and the Grant Fluted, plus the JustPack Rebound in polypropylene, which flexes under impact and is the one to choose if you have ever cracked a shell. See hard shell suitcases.

Choose a soft shell if

  • You drive and the boot is full. A soft case squashes; a hard case does not.
  • You come home with more than you took. Soft shells expand, and the fabric gives.
  • You want pockets: a front pocket for the documents, a laptop, the charger.
  • You travel with hand luggage and need to press the case into a sizer or under a seat.

Our soft shells: JustPack Aviate, which expands on every size, Grant Poplin and Tailored on eight wheels, the Kite with its 45 x 36 x 20 cm underseat size, and the Ezzyrol 222 with a 26 inch at 2.95 kg. See soft shell suitcases.

What people get wrong

Hard shells are heavier, but not by much. On our ranges a hard cabin case weighs 2.7 kg to 3 kg and a soft one about 2.3 kg; at 28 inch it is 4.2 kg to 4.6 kg against 3.3 kg to 3.5 kg. Hard shells are not waterproof. The zip lets water in if the case stands in a puddle. Soft shells are not weaker at the zip. Both types fail at the zip and the wheels first, which is why replaceable wheels matter more than the shell.

Questions people ask

Which is better, a hard or soft suitcase?

Hard for protection, rain and the hold; soft for squeezing, expanding and pockets. For a checked bag most people are better with hard; for a cabin bag it is personal preference.

Are hard shell suitcases heavier?

A little. On our ranges a hard cabin case weighs about half a kilo more than a soft one, and a 28 inch about a kilo more.

Do hard shell suitcases crack?

Cheap thin ABS can crack at the corners after years of hold handling. Thicker ABS with reinforced corners and polypropylene shells resist it; polypropylene is the toughest.

Can a soft suitcase go in the hold?

Yes. Pack shoes and hard things round the edges to protect the middle, and strap it. Our soft shells are checked in every day.

Which lasts longer?

About the same if the wheels and zips are good. A scuffed hard shell looks worse sooner; a torn soft shell is harder to repair.

Where to go next

More from the news